Dr. Sam Bommarito’s latest post argues that districts should “seek research‑based methods that best fit their population” and that teachers should be free to apply the art of teaching within those frameworks.
It sounds reassuring, but the reality is troubling: despite decades of “research‑based” phonics programmes, the percentage of children leaving school as functional illiterates has remained stubbornly flat. If research were truly guiding us toward effective solutions, shouldn’t those numbers have shifted by now?
What Research Hasn’t Explained
Flat illiteracy rates: Whether under Whole Language or phonics, functional illiteracy has persisted. Research has not explained why outcomes remain stagnant.
Instructional clarity: Many children disengage because they are confused by wrong sounds, added schwas, or inconsistent rules. Research that ignores this factor cannot account for persistent failure.
Dolch words: High‑frequency words make up 60% of print. Yet rote memorization of these words has been sidelined, undermining automaticity.
Multiple sounds per letter: Children are rarely told early that letters often represent more than one sound. This omission leaves them bewildered when phonics rules break down.
Misdiagnosis of causes: The dominant narrative blames phonological awareness deficits or English’s opacity. In reality, wrong teaching practices are the root cause.
Commercial interests: “Research‑based” often functions as a marketing label. As I noted in my exchange with Nora Chahbazi, many educators seem more interested in selling programmes than reducing illiteracy.
The Real Issue
The persistence of functional illiteracy is not a mystery of human cognition — it is the predictable result of instructional confusion. Children are not failing because English is opaque or because they lack phonological awareness. They are failing because they are taught incorrectly, and then blamed for the failure.
Until research confronts these blind spots — clarity of sounds, mastery of Dolch words, and early transparency about letter‑sound relationships — invoking “research‑based” will remain little more than rhetoric.
And tellingly, when I raised these very issues with Sam in a podcast discussion, he chose not to broadcast it. That silence speaks volumes. It shows how perspectives that challenge the mainstream “research‑based” narrative are often muted, maintaining the illusion of consensus while functional illiteracy persists.

2 comments:
Your assertion that it's not the high opacity of the English spelling system (1/2 of the lexicon) that causes failure is not provided. That's like ignoring the evidence that dull scalpels were given to surgeons & state they failed because they had bad training or technique.
Thank you, Shira. I agree completely that hope, self-regulation, and perseverance matter. My interest has always been in understanding what happens when a child who possesses those qualities nevertheless experiences repeated confusion and failure. In many cases, I have found that restoring success is the key. Once children begin succeeding again, hope, confidence, and perseverance often re-emerge remarkably quickly. Thank you for your thoughtful comment.
Thank you for taking the time to comment. I appreciate the challenge, and the scalpel analogy is a fair way to put the concern.
I am not arguing that English spelling is simple, or that irregularity does not make learning harder. About half the lexicon is irregular, and that is a real feature of the writing system. What I am arguing is that opacity, by itself, does not adequately explain why so many children still leave school unable to read, while many others learn the same system successfully.
If the tool were the decisive cause, we would expect more uniform failure. Instead, we see large differences that track instruction: children taught inconsistent letter–sound mappings, extra schwas, or delayed high-frequency word learning often become confused. Children given early, explicit notice that letters can represent more than one sound, plus systematic practice of the words that make up most of print, often do not.
So, the analogy, as I see it, is slightly different. The spelling system is the same “instrument” for every child. Some classrooms hand it over with a clear explanation of how it actually works; others hand it over with incomplete or contradictory instructions and then treat the child’s struggle as proof that the language itself is the problem.
I have not claimed that training is the only variable, or that research on opacity should be ignored. I have claimed that research which treats opacity as the main explanation, while leaving instructional confusion unexamined, cannot account for the flat outcomes we keep seeing. If you have studies that isolate opacity from teaching method and still show it as the primary driver of failure, I would be glad to read them.
Thank you again for pressing the point. This is exactly the discussion the topic needs.
Post a Comment