Why the Silence on Questions That Could Slash Illiteracy?
Purple Culture (purpleculture.net) positions itself as a go-to educational website for Chinese learners worldwide. It offers excellent free tools: Pinyin charts with audio, text-to-Pinyin converters, practice sheet generators, dictionaries, and resources for teachers and students. Headquartered with ties to Hong Kong and Beijing, it serves millions seeking accurate Mandarin mastery.
In a recent LinkedIn discussion, Professor Graham Kendall and Dr. Alice Hughes (University of Melbourne) emphasised the importance of formal peer review for any claim to become part of the scientific record. I pushed back firmly: when it comes to teaching children to read, some problems are glaringly obvious from real classroom experience. Real results with real children should drive immediate change — not be delayed for years by academic gatekeeping.
Flushing Out the Top Brains: U.S. and China’s Shared Tragedy
The U.S. has already shown us how to cripple its brightest children: teach letters with extraneous sounds. Logical kids hear buh for b, muh for m, and immediately detect the inconsistency. They shut down, not because they are “dyslexic,” but because the system itself is broken. The result? Curious, analytical children are flushed out of classrooms, mislabeled, and silenced.
Since 2004, I have been teaching children labelled "dyslexic" to read English by stripping away the "noise." I have seen time and again that when you remove extraneous sounds—like teaching 'b' as "buh"—the "dyslexia" often vanishes within weeks.
Now, we are seeing the exact same disaster unfold with Pinyin.
The Death of Clean Pinyin
In a recent discussion on Twitter (Now X) a teacher Jen@jenteach13 said:
You want to fix education?
Let teachers remove kids who make it impossible for everyone else to learn.
Recent studies show a startling trend in China: reported dyslexia prevalence has jumped from roughly 3.9% a decade ago to as high as 12.6% in recent urban research. While the biological traits of dyslexia remain stable, our instructional methods have shifted, creating a generation of students who appear to be struggling with reading but are actually victims of a confusing phonetic hybrid.
The Rise of the "Phantom Vowel"
We know the brain can learn to read. Some children, like Emma Hartnell-Baker, pick up Enid Blyton at age three with no instruction. But most aren’t so lucky. They need teaching — and the science is clear: everything hinges on connecting letters to sounds.
The following tweet captures a maddening truth:
Education is one of the few fields where people with no training feel entitled to dictate methods, policies, and “best practices.” Nobody would let a passerby advise a surgeon mid-operation or redesign an engineer’s bridge. Yet in classrooms—especially in reading instruction—voices from policymakers, academics, influencers, and even trainers who’ve never sat with a failing child often carry more weight than those who have.
The Star today reports a dual crisis for Chinese students in Malaysia: fewer candidates, fewer top scorers in the SPM. The shock is palpable. But let’s be blunt—this collapse didn’t come out of nowhere. It is the direct consequence of wrong teaching imported from China, and the silence of educators who refused to confront it.
The Bopomofo Infiltration
In 2004, I began teaching a bright young child to read. Like many educators at the time, I turned to the internet for guidance and encountered countless articles claiming that the primary cause of dyslexia was a phonological awareness deficit. This idea—that children with dyslexia struggle mainly because they can't properly perceive or manipulate the sounds in spoken language—dominated the conversation.
Not a single adult has ever openly discussed why many kids misbehave. Many who misbehave are intelligent kids.
This observation comes from years of working with struggling readers. The pattern is unmistakable: bright, capable children are often the ones who act out the most in class.
Early wrong input is hard to undo. Claude Bernard saw it in the 1800s. Thorndike proved it in 1913. Charlie Munger explained why the mind closes the door.
For years I have been warning about instructional videos that teach consonant sounds with extraneous “uh”. These videos don’t just confuse children — they cause many to disengage completely from learning to read.
A respected teacher recently posted:
“A dyslexic brain needs about 400 exposures to a word to anchor it in long-term memory.”
It sounds authoritative. It sounds scientific. But is it true?
Welcome to Part 7 of How to Teach Dyslexic Kids! By now your student has built strong foundations in phonics, multisensory techniques, and the finger-blocking method for spotting reliable patterns like ee, oo, and other vowel teams. This stage focuses on two powerful unlocks: R-controlled vowels (the “bossy r” sounds)
Syllable division rules — the key to cracking longer, multisyllabic words.
Now I understand why many parents and teachers of dyslexic kids have not bought my book, Teach Your Child to Read — which is a complete programme with a QR Code for each chapter.
A few days ago, I found myself in a thoughtful LinkedIn exchange with R. Janet Walraven, M.Ed., an international award-winning author and passionate educator. The topic? Helping children—especially those who struggle—learn to read confidently and correctly.
