Friday, November 20, 2026

If Six-Year-Olds Can Pronounce Consonants Correctly, Why Can't Reading Experts?

                                                         From Timothy Shanahan's Blog
 

 This morning I read Timothy Shanahan's latest post. LINK

Teacher question:

I was just told that the science of reading says that we shouldn’t teach blending or that we teach too much blending and should dial it back. Do you agree with that? 

Timothy Shanahan's response (extracts):

Studies have long supported blending instruction as part of explicit phonics teaching (Pflaum, et al., 1980; National Reading Panel, 2000), so I don’t agree with claims that addressing blending is a bad idea.

Synthetic phonics begins with individual letters (graphemes) and sounds (phonemes). Let’s say the students are taught the phonemes for the letters a, b, and d. Knowing those letters and sounds should allow a student to read or spell a word like bad.

Things don’t always work that way. Instead of “bad,” the result is often something more like, “buh, ah, duh,” leaving students perplexed. That isn’t reading.

That’s where blending instruction comes into play in synthetic phonics. The idea is to guide kids to do that gliding and to make those connections between phonemes.

The problem is that there’s no way to produce consonant phonemes without adding vowel sounds. They cannot be produced in isolation, so teaching kids a string of isolated letters and sounds, guarantees that you’ll end up with extra vowels.

Here is my comment on Shanahan’s post and let’s see his response:

Dear Dr. Timothy Shanahan,

You say: “The problem is that there’s no way to produce consonant phonemes without adding vowel sounds. They cannot be produced in isolation, so teaching kids a string of isolated letters and sounds guarantees that you’ll end up with extra vowels.”

In 2015, you asked me for research reports supporting my finding that a phonological awareness deficit is not the cause of dyslexia.

May I now ask you for research reports that support your claim that phonemes cannot be produced without adding vowel sounds?

I would also encourage you to get a copy of my book, Teach Your Child to Read LINK

Then tell me whether any consonants are pronounced with added vowel sounds.

Best regards,

Luqman Michel

 

Timothy: 

‘Teachers wisely try to minimize it by minimizing the extra vowel sounds – making them as small as possible. That helps, but it doesn’t necessarily solve the problem. Even when you minimize those pronunciations CVC words too often end up with 5 phonemes instead of 3.’

 

It appears that Shanahan is repeating what Mark Seidenberg said. 

If a 6-year-old child in Lagos can pronounce the consonants without extra vowel sounds Timothy and Seidenberg ought to be able to do so too. LINK.

Listen to this lady pronouncing the consonants. LINK

So, on what basis does Timothy say that consonants cannot be sounded out without extra vowel sounds? 

Timothy: 

‘The other type of phonics instruction is analytic phonics. There are various versions of this approach. Analytic phonics doesn’t teach blending as much as it tries to limit the need for it.

 

Teaching the pronunciation of these combinations reduces the likelihood that kids would have trouble blending, and that’s one of the reasons that some modern-day authorities encourage this kind of syllable teaching (Groff, 1981).’

Now, there is a fresh lipstick on the pig. LINK

 

Timothy: 

‘But like anything, it would be possible to overdo it. Kids only need that kind of instructional support until they can do it reasonably well – which usually doesn’t take very long. One way to minimize the problem is to get to larger units of pronunciation like rimes or morphemes early on. Those support kids blending progress, too.’

Many of my dyslexic students were able to read after lesson 7 in my book. Once their confusion of letter sounds was removed, they excelled.

It doesn’t matter what Timothy or Seidenberg say.

No comments: