Wednesday, November 24, 2021

Q&A Dr. Richard Selznick

 



Here is a Tweet for which I had no answer and had to refer to my mentor. I am posting this here as it may be useful to other readers.

 

Dr. K. Metropoulos @DrKMetropoulos

Question-what if a child sees N, but the printed letter is M? Phonemic awareness won’t mean anything because they aren’t seeing the letter others see. What can I do to help?

 

Sunday, November 21, 2021

No one wants to be sold but everyone wants to buy

 


I spoke to my son about what I tweeted to Tisha Rarendra (see below) and told him that I think she will not write as requested by me. He then told me that no one wants to be sold but everyone wants to buy and I have used that statement for the title above.

Tisha Rajendra @TishaRajendra Nov 20 Replying to @JoAnneGross1

Friday, November 19, 2021

Why and why not


Here is a tweet I read this morning responding to one of my tweets.

A Williams aka Ms. Worf @Ms_Worf Replying to @luqmanmichel and @MartinOdimaJr

Where I worked as an elementary teacher, they did very little to find out the why. Where I am now as a high school teacher, we focus on finding the why. Personally, finding and addressing the why is of extreme importance because no one tried to help me with my why.

Tuesday, November 16, 2021

Chalkbeat Colorado



 Chalkbeat Colorado is a nonprofit news organization reporting on education in Denver and the surrounding area. (From the internet.)

Early this month a zoom meeting by community@chalkbeat.org was announced on Twitter on the following topic.

Monday, November 15, 2021

Timothy Shanahan on phonemic awareness



Here are extracts from a post by Timothy Shanahan dated 13 November, 2021.

 

Timothy:

Not long ago, I dared question the evidence supporting the teaching of “advanced phonemic awareness.”

 

My comment:

This reminds me of my tweet and the response I received from KYEducator2018.

Saturday, November 13, 2021

Evidence requested by Jeffrey Bowers - anecdotal and Research reports


Here are extracts from a post by Jeffery Bowers and my comments.

 

Jeffrey Bowers:

I expect some advocates of phonics will say that the term “phonics” refers to knowledge of letter-sound correspondences, and children need to learn these correspondences to read aloud.  The problem with this is that almost all forms of reading instruction teach letter-sound correspondences, including whole language, balanced literacy, and SWI.  The issue at hand is whether phonics instruction (as defined in all the meta-analyses and government reports) is the best way to teach these mappings.

Wednesday, November 10, 2021

Common sense and teaching

 


 

I read an article a week ago. Here are a few extracts and my comments.

One sentence from the article that caught my eyes is: Once habits become ingrained they can be very hard to shift, even when we are presented with evidence that challenges them.

That statement reminds me of what Charlie Munger had said about how the human mind resembles the human egg. LINK.

Sunday, November 7, 2021

Fountas and Pinnell



The following are extracts from the Fountas Blog post. You may read the article here.

The goal for the reader is accuracy using all sources of information simultaneously. And that includes processing each letter in words from left to right. If a reader says “pony” for “horse” because of information from the pictures, that tells the teacher that the reader is using meaning information from the pictures, as well as the structure of the language, but is neglecting to use the visual information of the print. His response is partially correct, but the teacher needs to guide him to stop and work for accuracy.

"Try that again, and be sure what you read looks right and makes sense", or "Check the letters to be sure you are right."

The goal is for the child to stop or monitor, look more closely at the word and think about what would make sense and fit with the sequence of letters.

The bottom line is that a young reader must use everything he knows to move through a written text, to read it accurately and understand it. Multiple sources of information are combined in a complex and orchestrated way. The development of the child's ability to use all sources of information will take time and skillful teaching. It is impossible to boil down this process to something as simplistic as “don't think, just sound it out.”

Thursday, November 4, 2021

Opaque language vs transparent language

 



I have written 2 articles on this topic but I am prompted to write again on this as within a span of less than a week two dyslexia experts have said that kids are unable to read in English because it is an opaque language.

English is considered an opaque language because letters represent more than one sound.

Sunday, October 31, 2021

Three main reasons why kids disengage from learning to read

 



Here are the 3 main reasons why kids shut down/ disengage from learning to read. I learned this directly from the experts, my students.

This is what my blog has repeatedly said for the past decade.

i.                     Teach the correct pronunciation of sounds represented by consonants

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGGr4uyFdn4

 

Doing the same things over and over expecting different results.

 


Educators have been doing the same things for decades expecting different results. Most of what they write is general and does not add value.

Friday, October 29, 2021

Dyslexia or Instructional Casualties

 


This morning I had a tweet from www.understood.org in response to my tweet. They linked the following resource. LINK


Here are excerpts and my response.

Dyslexia is a common condition that makes it hard to read. Some experts believe that between 5 and 10 percent of people have it. Others say as many as 17 percent of people show signs of reading challenges.

Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Main cause of teacher stress and how to avoid it



Yesterday, I read a post by Dr Mary Bousted @MaryBoustedNEU which prompted me to write this post.

Dr Mary Bousted is joint general secretary, with Kevin Courtney, of the National Education Union @NEUnion.

This was her tweet:

The govt. is, apparently, going to focus on getting ‘better’ teachers. Here’s the thing - they have the best teachers ever at the moment. The problem is that far too many leave because the same govt. has made teaching an almost impossible job.

Wednesday, October 20, 2021

Sounds represented by letters

This post is in response to a Tweet by Lucky Girl.

LuckyGirlLinguist @GinaCookeLEX Oct 18 Replying to @luqmanmichel @jeffrey_bowers and 4 others.

“You're betraying your ignorance. There is no such thing as the correct pronunciation of phonemes. Phonemes are abstract psychological categories, not pronounced phonetic units. Phone memes are pronounced differently in different words and different dialects, and that's normal.” (Lucky Girl Linguist)

Friday, October 15, 2021

My challenge to Jeffrey Bowers

 


Jeffrey, why don’t you do the research yourself with my guidance? Get a few teachers around the US or around the world to teach kids in grades 1 to 3 who are unable to read. Ensure they do not have acuity problems. That is, they do not have sharpness or keenness of thought, vision, or hearing.