Friday, January 21, 2022

Balanced Literacy or SOR - my comments on Dr. Sam Bommarito's blog post

 


On 16.1.2022, I read a post on Dr. Sam Bommarito’s blog. Here are a few extracts and my comments.


Dr. Sam:

 

On the one hand, everyone agrees that the current state of reading instruction is not acceptable. SOR advocates claim Balanced Literacy is the root cause of the problems in reading. They view Balanced Literacy as lacking instruction in phonics and the use of orthographic information.

 

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

My second student in 2021

 


I had stopped teaching in 2019 but started guiding parents to teach their kids who were unable to read.

Here is an email I received from the mother of my latest student whom I weaned off last week.

Jan 17, 2022, 8:15 AM      

Good morning Mr Luqman,

Sunday, January 16, 2022

Too simple – a view by a podcaster

 


On December 17th 2020, I was invited to a Zoom meeting by a Podcaster who happened to have read some of my Tweets. It was a half hour interview and I answered all his questions. He was jovial and our zoom meeting ended on a good note. 

 

On 26.12.2020 I received the following email from him.

Friday, January 14, 2022

Blocking for business reasons or due to delivery?

 


On 12.1.2021 I Tweeted the following:

‘Interesting find.

I just realised that one Gale Morrison @GaleMorrisonEd, Parent education advocate, has blocked me. Why do people block me? I believe I am a threat to their business.’

 

Tuesday, January 11, 2022

Greg Ashman's 'Throwing the kitchen sink at reading' and my comments

  


Here are some extracts from a post by Greg Ashman and my comments. I have told this guy to stick with what he is good at - Math and Physics – and not to stick his fingers in what he knows nothing about but this guy is just too stubborn or naive.  I have not seen his tweets for a long time as he decided to mute me for asking questions he could not respond to. He has learned well from the ostrich.

Monday, January 10, 2022

The successful dyslexic

     


This book is written by Mike Thomas who is a dyslexic.

Here are a few extracts and my comments/questions which I hope Mike will respond to.

 

The second time through the 4th grade I started listening more closely to what the teacher was saying and focusing harder on the material I was studying. As a result, I did start to get a little better at reading. Sure, I was still very slow at reading, but now I tried concentrating on memorizing exactly what each word sounded like as I was looking at it; linking the sound of the word with the image of the word.

 

This seemed to work, but I had to literally hear every word in my head as I read it to know its meaning.
I thought that was just the way everybody read, hearing each word in their heads as they read.

Tuesday, January 4, 2022

Meaning of shut down kids

 

                                                     https://notionpress.com/read/shut-down-kids


In 2018, when I wanted to write a book based on what I had learned from my students since 2004 I searched for a title. I decided on ‘Shut Down Kids’ based on Shut Down Learner written by Dr. Richard Selznick.

 

When I say ‘shut down kids’ it is not derogatory in any way and just refers to the fact that about 20% of kids around the world disengage from learning to read when they are confused. These kids are then classified as dyslexic when in fact they are instructional casualties. These are the kids who leave school as functional illiterates.

Sunday, January 2, 2022

Nora Chahbliz and the 'Truth about Reading'

 


On 29.12.2021 I saw a comment by Nora Chahbliz on Nancy Bailey’s blog post. Nora Chahbliz aids the producers and director of the documentary: “The Truth About Reading”.

 

Based on the trailer she had viewed, Nancy mentioned that the documentary is missing truths.

 

Nora Chahbliz commented on Nancy’s post asking if Nancy would consider an interview.

Friday, December 31, 2021

“The Truth About Reading” Is Missing Truths...by Nancy Bailey (Part 3)


 


‘I cannot teach anybody anything, I can only make them think.’ –Socrates

 

Unfortunately, for most people thinking is one of the most difficult things to do.

 

Here is a comment in Nancy Baily’s blog post, by someone who is helping the director and producer.

Nora Chahbazi says         November 6, 2021 at 7:36 am

Thursday, December 30, 2021

Rayyan, a 6 year-old, reading from my book

 



Sometime early this year, my friend N. POOLOHGASINGAM aka Huang Poh Lo, complained to me that his grandson Rayyan was unable to read in English despite all the coaching he had given Rayyan.

I then asked Poh Lo how he taught the sounds of a few consonants to Rayyan viz. b, c, f, m, t and s. He sounded all the letters with extraneous sounds – buh, kuh, fuh, muh, tuh and sir/sur. 

The truth about Reading - Nancy Bailey (Part 2)


Here are further comments on Nancy Bailey’s post and my response.

Every child needs to be carefully evaluated as to why they aren’t doing well in reading.

My response:

Yes! This can be done as early as in the middle of grade 1. If a kid is unable to read like a majority of the other kids, then we need to find out why. If the kid has no acuity problems, then chances are he has shut down from learning to read due to confusion.

Wednesday, December 29, 2021

“The Truth About Reading” Is Missing Truths and Backstory by Nancy Bailey (Part 1)


 

Here is a post in Nancy Bailey’s blog. It is a comment on a trailer of an upcoming movie  “The Truth About Reading”.


Nancy says among other matters: 

Tuesday, December 28, 2021

Mark Seidenberg on becoming phonemic

 


Here is part 2 of the YouTube video by Mark Seidenberg, Molly Farry – thorn, Maryellen Macdonald (expert on speech production).

 

At minute 6.05 Mark Says:

‘Reader must fill in how to go from three discrete phone /b/a/t/ (he pronounces it as /buh/ ah/ tuh/) to one integrated syllable /bat/.

Maryellen: It is easier for certain phonemes than others. I believe phonemes including vowels and some consonants that can be stretched out a little are better for teaching kids blending so buh is hard to blend but M is mmmahhttt is an easier path to mat than bat. Different consonants have different properties that will make it more or less easy to be blended.

Mark: The properties of phonemes are such that they can’t be pronounced literally in isolation. I mean they are not parts of speech.

Sunday, December 26, 2021

Can Dyslexia Be Artificially Induced in School?

 



I saw the following link on a Tweet by Faith Borkowsky.

Here are a few extracts any my comments.

Ever since The New Illiterates was published back in 1973, we have known that the chief, and perhaps only cause of dyslexia among school children has been and still is the look-say, whole-word, or sight method of teaching reading. In that book I revealed the fact that the sight method was invented back in the 1830s by the Rev. Thomas H. Gallaudet, the director of the American Asylum at Hartford for the Education of the Deaf and Dumb. He had been using a sight, or whole-word method in teaching the deaf to read, by juxtaposing a word, such as cat, with the picture of a cat. And because the deaf were able to identify many simple words in this way, Gallaudet thought that the method could be adapted for use by normal children.

Wednesday, December 22, 2021

Neurological processing - December edition of Nomanis

 


This article, written by Rosalie Martin, appeared in the Dec 2021 edition of Nomanis.


Here are extracts and my comments.

Following the evidence

 

But high-quality evidence from studies across the world point at reading and writing as tasks overwhelmingly mediated by the phonemic (speech sound) processing areas of our brains. It has been shown that this continues to be so, even in accomplished readers and writers. The brain integrates print-based information with spoken language through neurological processing that is phonemically based.